Presentations from ACE 2007 Conference

ACE 2007 Presentations

Below you find the presentations made at the 5th annual conference of the Association of Competition Economics on November 29-30, 2007 at Université de Toulouse 1. 


Plenary Session

Keynote speech by Damien Neven, Chief Economist, DG Competition, European Commission. 


Round Table on "Buyer Power"

Chairman: Massimo Motta, professor, EUI and Università di Bologna 


John Fingleton, CEO, Office of Fair Trading, GB 

Buyer Power


Damien Neven, Chief Economist, DG Competition, European Commission 


Roman Inderst, Professor, University of Frankfurt (IMFS) & LSE 

Treatment of Buyer Power


Panel I: Article 82 and Predation: The Wanadoo case

Chairman: Alison Oldale, LECG, GB 


Miguel de la Mano, CET, DG Competition, European Commission 

The use (and abuse) of price-cost tests for predation: Lessons from the Wanadoo case


Jérôme Philippe, Freshfields, FR 

The Wanadoo Case


Giancarlo Spagnolo, Università di Roma 'Tor Vergata', SITE, Stockholm School of Economics 

Wild Thoughts on Predatory Abuses in Highly Dynamic Innovative Industries With Network Externalities and Product Complementarities


Panel II: Horizontal Mergers: Merger in the salmon market

Chairman: Peter Møllgaard, Copenhagen Business School, DK 

Intro: Horizontal mergers: Merger in the salmon market


Diana Jackson, Charles Rivers Associates Intl., GB 

Pan Fish/Marine Harvest:Three theories of harm, two competition authorities, and a remedy


Romain Lesur, Conseil de la Concurrence, FR 

Unilateral effects in Cournot markets with differentiated products


Benoît Durand, Competition Commission, GB 


Panel III: Case presentation: Svitzer/Wijsmuler

Chairman: Andrea Coscelli, Charles Rivers Associates Intl., GB 


Andrea Lofaro, RBB, GB 

Svitzer/Adsteam: Assessing unilateral effects when monopolists merge


Adam Land, Competition Commission, GB 

SvitzerWijsmuller A/S and Adsteam Marine Ltd


Mats Bergman, Uppsala University & Södertörn University College 

Potential competition as a competitive constraint


Panel IV: Article 82 and Predation: the Glaxo case

Chairman: Konrad Stahl, University of Mannheim, D 

Article 82 and Predation:The (French) Glaxo Case


Philippe Choné, Conseil de la Concurrence, FR 

The GSK France Decision of March 2007


Michele Polo, University of Bocconi and LECG, I 

The GSK France case: in search of a consistent story


Eric Avanel, University of Grenoble, FR 

An academic outsider’s view on the Glaxo case


Panel V: Vertical mergers and competition: The EWS-Marcroft case

Chairman: Pierluigi Sabbatini, Italian Competition Authroity, I 


Adam Land, Competition Commission, GB 

English Welsh & Scottish Railway Holdings Ltd (“EWS”)/ Marcroft Holdings Ltd


Neil Pratt, Frontier Economics, GB 

Vertical mergers - EWS/Marcroft


Roman Inderst, LSE and University of Frankfurt 

EWS/Marcroft: Market Definition and Incentives for Foreclosure


Panel VI: Potentially excessive prices and switching costs: banking cases from Hungary (OTP Bank)

Chairman: Anne Perrot, Conseil de la Concurrence, FR 


Gergely Csorba, Hungarian Competition Commission, H 

Rights for unilateral contact modifications as a potencial source of market power: the OTP Bank cases


Norbert Maier, London Economics, GB 

Increasing Early Settlement Charges for Personal Loans by OTP-Bank Hungaryn - Abuse of Dominant Position or a Rational Business Response to a Demand Shock?


Bruno Jullien, University of Toulouse 1, FR 

Potentially excessive prices and switching costs: banking cases from Hungary (OTP Bank)


Panel VII: Article 82 - Microsoft: "Rights", "Wrongs" and Priorities for Economic Analysis

Chairman: Yannis Katsoulacos, Athens University of Economics and Business, G 

Commission Vs. Microsoft: "Rights", "Wrongs" and Priorities for Economic Analysis


Amelia Fletcher, Office of Fair Trading, GB 

The CFI Microsoft Judgment: Abuse 1 - Interoperability


Matthew Bennet, LECG, GB 

Some comments on the Microsoft CFI Judgement


Paul Seabright, University of Toulouse 1, FR 

After Commission vs. Microsoft: Priorities for Economic Analysis


Panel VIII: Case presentation: Ryanair/Aer Lingus

Chairman: Mark Williams, NERA, GB and B 


Adrian Majumdar, RBB, B 

RYANAIR / AER LINGUS: Merger of highly differentiated services


Giulio Federico, Charles Rivers Associates Intl, B 

Ryanair / Aer Lingus: A politicised case


Marc Ivaldi, University of Toulouse 1, FR 

Ryanair / Aer Lingus case: Some comments


Coordinated effects: the Sony case

Chairman: Valérie Rabassa, DGCCRF, FR 


Simon Pilsbury, Oxera, GB 

The Impala case at the CFI